Atlantic ocean currents are near collapse. That could bury Europe in glaciers.
The Economist gets it right. Only complete destruction by atomic bombs could cause greater damage to Europe. And when they say it's a strategic problem requiring a strategic response, they're right.
EDITOR’S NOTE: A couple of years ago, I published this article for PolitiSage subscribers on the slowdown of AMOC—the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. This is the worldwide current and series of gyres that keep the world from turning into Snowball Earth. The collapse of the AMOC happens occasionally, but (thank God) rarely, and it is normally preceded by a melting of glaciers and ice sheets that dilute the salt into the ocean, causing the “chimneys”—seven gigantic whirlpools that take warm water from the surface of the earth to the earth’s crust with such power they force the circulation of waters worldwide—to shut down.
This morning in The Economist, an article crystallizes the panic that has been running through the scientific community in the last couple of months. Here’s their bottom line:
Those who think about national security love to bandy acronyms such as ATACMS (Army Tactical Missile System) and WOMBAT (Weapon of Magnesium, Battalion, Anti-Tank). They need to add AMOC to the list. The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation is not a weapons system. But it could lay waste a continent—specifically, Europe—to an extent that only a nuclear war could outmatch.
I began my studies in meteorology as a child, taught by my brilliant father, and continued them with Dr. Carl Berman, a Woods Hole research ship’s captain and professor of meteorology at the University of Maryland. I studied oceanography with Dr. George Buckley at Harvard. He is a famed ocean diver and a former director of Woods Hole director. I hope the following will prove useful in understanding what’s going on and how serious a climate issue this is.
This article is hereby placed in the public domain by Morgaan Rhys-Davies Sinclair, Ph.D.
They are, truly, the stuff of myth and legend. Odysseus, on his journey home, encountered the monster Charybdis, whose great thirst for the sea thrice a day created a great maelstrom that consumed men and ships. Now we place this maelstrom near Messina and Scilla in the narrow strait between Italy and Sicily. It is this whirlpool in this place that proved so threatening to seafarers that it appeared not only in The Odyssey but also in the myths of Jason and the Argonauts and in the stories of the Trojan Aeneas.
But it was not these Mediterranean sea spinners that captivated earth scientists in 1970. It was the spinning of the North Atlantic maelstroms—seven huge whirlpools in the Greenland and Norwegian Seas called chimneys—that would lead to a stunning revelation filled with wonders and fears. The chimneys, scientists learned, were a part of an ocean turbine system—the northern part. The southern part is the current that circles the globe while while it circles Antarctica.
Together these currents run a global “conveyor belt” of ocean water that both cools and warms the planet—releasing excess heat near the Arctic Circle while simultaneously warding off the next ice age by keeping the world warm enough that it doesn’t freeze.
Worldwide, north and south, the circulation of the seas is slowing down. That’s trouble.
First let’s look at the whole world. This image, by German physicist Stefan Rahmstorf, shows the planet’s major ocean currents, which, combined are called Global Thermohaline Circulation. Thermo means “heat,” and saline means “salt.” The whole system runs on the density of the water that is provided by the salt (which makes it heavy) and differences in water temperature. More on that in a minute.
In this image the red flows are warm water near the oceans’ surfaces—and blue and purple lines are cold, deep waters. But the real stars of this show are the four yellow ovals—two in the extreme north and two in the extreme south. Those are the chimneys—the maelstroms that are the turbines that keep the water moving worldwide.
Where these yellow ovals are, the currents release the heat they’ve picked up traveling on the surfaces. Now, of course, they’re very near the poles, and it’s cold. Some of the water is taken up as ice—but its salts are left behind. Salt doesn’t freeze, so all the ice is made up of pure H2O (fresh water) with its salt discarded. Now all the fluid water is super-saturated with salt, making it incredibly heavy, and this dense, heavy, cold water falls by its own weight.
The chimneys begin to spin, swirling down almost two miles to the ocean floor. The water is incredibly cold. The chimneys “flip” the water in the seas—and are known as Meridional Overturning Circulations.
Now the water travels in the deep canyons near the ocean floor, but eventually it rises due to the shape of undersea terrain. Now, exposed to the sun and its salts diluted by fresher water at the surface, the currents warm. Having made a trip from the North Atlantic virtually all around the world, their last detour before heading back to the North Atlantic—a quick trip to the Gulf of Mexico—means the water arriving in the Greenland and Norwegian Seas is very warm. But here, again, the water meets the Arctic cold, its freshwater is taken up in ice (at least at some times of the year), and the remaining water, now cold and dense and salty, plunges again to the ocean floor.
So, these are the four chimneys. But they are not all created equal: it’s the sea around Antarctica that’s really running the show. It is the strongest current on earth and flows clockwise.
Double-click on the replay link below for a moving image of the Antarctica Circumpolar Current (ACC) for the last few years.
Video Credit: Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research. If you can’t get this to play (I’m having mixed results!), go to You Tube and type in FESOM CURRENTS AROUND ANTARCTICA and it’ll come right up.
The Antarctic current looks as if its flow is self-contained, that all of it is just going ‘round and ‘round in a circle. Much of it is—but not all of it.
Looking at the world from the south, you can see the circular current around the South Pole—and also how it feeds into and pushes global ocean current circulation—in three oceans.
What happens if the ACC Slows Down?
Rising global temperature, caused by carbon emissions, is melting ice caps, pouring massive quantities of fresh water into the oceans. New scientific modelling by MIT, Australian National University, and the University of New South Wales indicates that more fresh water could slow down deep water circulation more than 40 per cent by 2050 – putting it on a path towards collapse.
“Our study shows that the melting of the ice sheets has a dramatic impact on the overturning circulation that regulates Earth’s climate,” says Dr. Adele Morrison, from ACEAS and the ANU Research School of Earth Sciences.
With collapse of the deep current, oceans below 13,000 feet (4,000 meters) would stagnate and cause impacts for centuries, trapping nutrients in the deep ocean away from marine life near the surface. It would decimate sea life as we know it.
And it could trigger a new ice age. Hence the hyperbole about The Day After Tomorrow.
The new study’s scientific modeling is based on a “high emissions scenario” that is all too likely to continue. The melting of the polar ice sheets and the collapse of Antarctic ice shelves is expected to accelerate as the planet heats up.
What Happens If Overturning Stops at Both Poles? Maybe Another Younger Dryas Period.
The Younger Dryas was a cool period between roughly 12,900 and 11,600 years ago that interrupted the warming trend in t he Northern Hemisphere at the end of the last ice age. It was a sudden, devastating climate shift. Its onset took less than 100 years, and it lasted thirteen centuries. It returned large parts of the Northern Hemisphere to ice age conditions.
So what happened?
At the end of the last ice age, the glacier over North America, the Laurentide Ice Sheet, started melting and retreating. It left behind a huge inland sea called Lake Agassiz that covered a large part of north-central North America. Rather than draining into the Mississippi River, its waters flowed into the North Atlantic in the area that is now the St. Lawrence Seaway.
As the fresh water diluted the salinity of the northern oceans, the chimneys shut down. The turbines no longer turned. There were no maelstroms to carry the cold water to the sea floor.
Global Thermohaline Circulation, at least in the North Atlantic and possibly worldwide, shut down for 1,300 years. The result was a mini-ice age in the northern climes and a slight warming in the Southern Hemisphere. Populations, human and animal, in the northern latitudes were decimated. Flora species changed dramatically all over Europe and North America. Populations at mid-latitudes began to become more nomadic, following food supplies.
When the salinity-density of North Atlantic waters recovered and the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation of the chimneys began to spin again, the Younger Dryas ended even more rapidly than it began, with warming to previous temperatures taking as little as 10 months.
If a Younger Dryas were to happen now, with populations packed tightly into urban centers with millions of people, it could kill billions of people as well as destroying unimaginable resources in flora and fauna. Mechanical and digital technologies would grind to a halt.
Both the Antarctic Circumpolar Circulation and the Global Thermohaline Circulation are slowing down. Of particular concern is the one at the bottom of the world, which has so much impact on the sea circulations of three oceans and such power to stop the flow of the nutrients that sustain sea life.
Scientists are desperately calling for immediate action to severely limit carbon emissions and to sequester as much of what is already in the atmosphere as we can.
It isn’t like scientists to be melodramatic. In invoking The Day After Tomorrow, they are sounding an alarm they feel must be heard. We are running out of time.
THE FULL ECONOMIST ARTICLE IS HERE;
A subscription is required, but they do give folks five free articles a month. This is worth spending one of your freebies!
Horrifying!
Is it reasonable to assume that all world leaders and governments know this information? That China, Russia, Australia, the EU and the USA know this? And that the tech bros know this? If yes, then their racial supremacy agendas, genocide-by-design economics, carbon emissions free-for-all fits into a racial supremacy-driven land grab for survival?
What does this do to equatorial flora and fauna? Does any region allow survival of species-dense ecosystems? Or does this become a global paring down?
What are the carbon-sequestering techniques that can operate at scale?
USA maga-dominated government knows this is happening - why would they promote climate denial and complete abandonment of efforts to reverse carbon-emissions? For the energy-land grab plus short term monetary gains?
So confusing. They know it’s happening. And that the data are factual. Denial is cheaper? Are they really that shortsighted? Holy moly.